The thing about the Hens is that no matter how snippy they are toward their opponents, they are much worse to one another. They have a lot to say to and about their opponents as well so it makes for a lot of chatter.
Hen #1 is clucking at Hen #2. I’m tuning them out, staring into the middle distance while absentmindedly shuffling my cards. I’m wondering if perhaps I could have made that contract after all, of course, I’m pretty happy with down one. I don’t think it could be made, but my feeling of contentment is short lived. My attention is drawn back to the present by the silence of the Hens; they have ceased their clucking and are looking at me expectantly.
“Sorry?”
“What did you have?” Hen #1 asks.
I shrug, shoving the packet of cards securely into the board, “Thirteen HCP, five hearts …”
“And in diamonds?” Hen #2.
“Three small.” It’s an admission, kind of.
“I’m reporting you for a psyche bid,” Hen #1′s feathers are ruffled, “Director!” And then to Hen #2, “If she wants to play games …”
“If I didn’t want to play games, I wouldn’t be in a bridge club,” I mutter, but they hear me. The Hens fall silent. The director arrives at the table. The Hens begin to squawk. My partner who has until this point been silent jumps into the fray. Things are getting ugly. The director wants to see my hand. This particular director seems not to like me very much. Once in the midst of explaining to her partner just why the score they had gotten was so bad, she gestured at me while saying, “Well a NORMAL person would have bid …” At the time it made my night, but it was a rather grim reflection at this particular moment.
“It’s not a pysch bid!” my partner is yelling. The whole club is silent. Everyone is staring; no one is playing. I’m silent too. The director is staring at me now, “If you make another bid like that you’ll be penalized a quarter board or something, I don’t know what it is. Don’t make me look it up.” I nod. I don’t think it was a psych. I think it was a bad bid and I think I got away with it. I think the opponents are pretty angry that they let me get away with it. I’m going to agree so that everyone will be quiet and we can get on to the second hand of the day. I’m going to agree so that the director won’t penalize my partner for insubordination, though I assume if there is one, she’d have to look up the penalty for that as well. I’m going to agree because there are far worse things than having a reputation as someone who on occasion makes a psych bid.
Later my partner will demand a definition of a psych bid, and, then subsequently a definition of the word “grossly”. But for now peace is restored at the table and we’re on to the next hand. The Hens’ bidding goes astray somewhere and soon enough they are clucking at each other again which is as it should be.
An e-mail I sent to one of my regular partners retelling the events of the day was met by a story about the Hens insisting that a penalty double of a 1NT opening bid should have been alerted. They had called the director after the hand had been played and insisted the declarer would have played the hand differently had they known that the double had been for penalty. To their mind, not only are all artificial bids alertable, so are all natural bids they don’t like.
The next day I arrive at the club and as I approach that day’s director to pay my card fee, she greets me with “No psyching! And if you do psych you have to tell them after the bidding,” I stare, mouth slightly agape. I’m trying to decide if that’s an ACBL rule or a club rule or what. I manage to shut my mouth before saying anything I might regret. She wasn’t going to let me get a word in edgewise anyway, and eventually I realize she’s talking about a different hand from another day entirely. Not a psych bid either, for the record, I’d just forgotten we were playing a conventional 2♦ opening. I got a good result. The opponents claimed they didn’t double me in 5♦ because they thought my opening had been a full opening hand; but either they believe me or they believe their partner and once I pull my partner’s double of 4♠ it should be clear who’s lying. Still I can think of worse things than being a player that other people assume is psyching when in reality I’ve just forgotten what I agreed to play.
A few days later an eMail landed in my inbox from one of the friendlier experts who was there the day the director had been called. His e-mail said he “partly overheard” (which is a polite way of saying, he couldn’t help but overhear) and wanted to know the particulars of the hand in question (if I didn’t mind, of course, he really is very nice) because he’d never heard of such a ruling. I sent him the hand, noted that I didn’t think it was a psych. He spoke to a couple of local tournament directors who agreed it wasn’t a psych (the consensus seems to be it wasn’t a psych, just a bad bid). The Hens, it turns out, are known to these tournament directors, one noted that he spent half his time at their table whenever they played in an event. The other noted that they were experienced enough that I should have gotten the bad bid shoved down my throat (I’m paraphrasing, but that was the gist of it) and that they are in particular known for not alerting their own system properly. I’ve witnessed that first hand, but I’m not much for calling the director — especially ones who don’t like me.
In the end, I’m left pondering an important question: Just when does a bad big become a psych? After all, I have a reputation to consider.